Both Can Be True
on Goodreads (1,869)
What’s inside...
Two kids, Ash and Daniel, bond over rescuing a dog named Chewbarka that's about to be euthanized. As they navigate their own struggles with identity and acceptance, they develop feelings for each other. However, things get complicated as Daniel initially perceives Ash as only a girl, unaware of Ash's fluid gender identity. Together, they face challenges related to truth, identity, and acceptance, while finding comfort in their unique friendship and their love for Chewbarka. The story is a celebration of living beyond societal binaries and embracing one's true self.
Age
8-12
Length
368 pages
Text complexity
Character compass
Ash
Daniel
Discussion points
How did the character Ash's experience with identity resonate with you? What feelings or thoughts did it bring up?
What are some ways that you can be supportive of friends who are experiencing challenges, similar to how Ash and Daniel supported each other?
Why do you think it's important for everyone to feel accepted for who they truly are?
How can embracing our differences make us stronger as a community?
What are some steps you can take to explore and express your own identity, like Ash did?
Tip: Role play these questions
Encourage your child to express their thoughts and feelings openly, without judgment, to foster a safe space for discussion.
Relate themes from the book to real-life situations or current events to make the discussion more relevant and engaging.
Ask follow-up questions based on your child's responses to deepen the conversation and encourage critical thinking.
Highlight the importance of empathy and understanding by discussing the characters' perspectives and motivations.
Use examples from the book to discuss the value of friendship, acceptance, and self-discovery.
Key lessons
Example Lesson: Embracing Identity
Explanation: The protagonist, Ash, navigates complex feelings about gender identity and ultimately learns the importance of being true to oneself.
Real-World Application: Children can understand the value of self-acceptance and expressing their true selves, enhancing their confidence and interpersonal relationships.
Example Lesson: Empathy and Understanding
Explanation: Through Ash’s friendship with Daniel, readers see how empathy builds strong, supportive relationships, as they learn to understand each other's unique struggles.
Real-World Application: Kids are encouraged to practice empathy in their daily interactions, fostering a more inclusive and supportive environment at school and home.
Example Lesson: Courage to Face Challenges
Explanation: Both Ash and Daniel face personal and social challenges, showing courage as they confront and overcome them.
Real-World Application: This lesson inspires children to tackle difficulties, whether in adjusting to new situations or standing up for themselves and others.
Example Lesson: Importance of Supportive Friendships
Explanation: The story highlights how Daniel’s understanding and support help Ash feel less alone and more accepted, demonstrating the power of friendship.
Real-World Application: Children learn to seek out and cultivate supportive friendships, which are essential for emotional and social development.
Example Lesson: Resilience in Adversity
Explanation: Despite the hurdles faced by the characters, they show resilience throughout their journeys.
Real-World Application: This teaches children to remain resilient in the face of challenges, helping them develop a robust approach to problems in their lives.