Karen's Brothers (Baby-sitters Little Sister #17)
#17 of 131 in The Baby-Sitters Club Series
What’s inside...
Karen Brewer feels stuck in the middle—she has an older stepbrother, Charlie, a younger half-brother, Andrew, and twin baby brothers on the way at her dad’s house. When Karen suddenly decides she wants a "real" brother at each home, she begins matchmaking, begging her mother for another baby, and meddling in her brother Charlie’s social life. Her schemes cause mix-ups at school, tension at home, and eventually a heart-to-heart that helps Karen understand that families can be perfect even when they do not look exactly the same. Through gentle humor and everyday situations, the book explores blended-family dynamics, jealousy, and acceptance.
Character compass
Karen Brewer
Andrew Brewer
Hannie Papadakis
Nancy Dawes
Sam Thomas
Discussion points
Why did Karen feel jealous of other kids’ brothers?
How did Karen’s plans affect Charlie and her parents?
What finally helped Karen accept her family as it is?
Can you think of a time misunderstandings caused problems in your life?
Tip: Role play these questions
Share personal stories about siblings and blended families.
Role-play how Karen could have voiced her feelings earlier.
Key lessons
Example Lesson: Acceptance
Explanation: Karen learns her family is already complete.
Real-World Application: Appreciate the loved ones you have.
Example Lesson: Honesty
Explanation: Karen’s secret plans backfire until she tells the truth.
Real-World Application: Share feelings openly instead of hiding them.
Example Lesson: Empathy
Explanation: Karen understands Charlie’s perspective after apologizing.
Real-World Application: Consider others’ feelings before acting.
